5 Signature Grilled Cheese Sandwiches You Need to Try
These aren't your average grilled cheese sandwiches. Each one has been perfected over years of serving hungry crowds, tested at hundreds of events, and loved by thousands of guests. Here are the five sandwiches that made Grilly Cheese one of the top-rated food trucks in New Jersey.
Grilly Cheese was named one of the Top 6 Grilled Cheese spots in the nation by GrubHub in 2024. These signature sandwiches are why.
1The Grilly Cheese (Our Namesake)
This is the sandwich that started it all. A perfect balance of flavors that keeps guests coming back for seconds (and thirds).
What's Inside:
- Cheese blend: Sharp white cheddar + American + a touch of gruyère
- The twist: House-made bacon jam with hints of maple and black pepper
- Bread: Thick-cut sourdough, buttered and griddled to golden perfection
Guest favorite pairing: Our signature tomato soup
2The Cluck Norris
For those who want something heartier, The Cluck Norris delivers. Crispy chicken meets melty cheese in a sandwich that packs a serious punch.
What's Inside:
- Protein: Crispy fried chicken tenders, hand-breaded daily
- Cheese blend: Pepper jack + white American
- The twist: Hot honey drizzle and house pickles
- Bread: Brioche bun, buttered and pressed
Heat level: Medium – adjustable to your preference
3The Mac Attack
Yes, we put mac and cheese inside a grilled cheese. Yes, it's as incredible as it sounds. This is comfort food turned up to eleven.
What's Inside:
- The star: Creamy house-made mac and cheese with shell pasta
- Cheese blend: Three-cheese blend (cheddar, fontina, parmesan)
- The twist: Crispy bacon bits and a bread crumb topping
- Bread: Texas toast for maximum surface area
Pro tip: Ask for extra crispy – we'll press it a little longer for maximum crunch
4The Figgy Piggy
Sweet meets savory in this sophisticated sandwich. The Figgy Piggy is our most requested option for weddings and upscale events.
What's Inside:
- Cheese: Creamy brie + aged gouda
- Protein: Thinly sliced prosciutto
- The twist: House-made fig jam + fresh arugula
- Bread: Artisan sourdough
Perfect for: Wine pairings and elegant events
5The Classic (Elevated)
Sometimes you want a classic grilled cheese – but better. This is that sandwich. Simple, perfect, and exactly what you're craving.
What's Inside:
- Cheese blend: American + aged cheddar (the perfect melt-to-flavor ratio)
- The twist: European-style butter, griddled low and slow
- Bread: Bakery-fresh white pullman, sliced thick
Add-ons available: Tomato, bacon, or caramelized onions
Vegetarian & Dietary Options
All of our cheese sandwiches can be made vegetarian. We also offer:
- Vegan cheese option: Available on request with advance notice
- Gluten-free bread: Available at most events
- Dairy-free: Ask about our current dairy-free options
Why These Sandwiches Work for Events
When planning catering, you need food that works for everyone. Our signature sandwiches:
- Cook quickly: 3-4 minute cook time means no long wait lines
- Travel well: Perfect for passed appetizers or stationed service
- Satisfy everyone: From kids to executives, everyone loves grilled cheese
- Create buzz: Guests talk about the food truck experience for months
- Photograph beautifully: That cheese pull is pure social media gold
The Full Menu Experience
At events, we typically serve 3-4 sandwich options plus sides. A popular combo:
Recommended Event Menu
- Sandwich 1: The Grilly Cheese (crowd favorite)
- Sandwich 2: The Figgy Piggy (upscale option)
- Sandwich 3: The Classic (safe choice for picky eaters)
- Sides: Tomato soup shots, house-made chips, pickles
Try These Sandwiches at Your Event
Book Grilly Cheese for your next wedding, corporate event, or party. We'll bring these award-winning sandwiches right to your guests.